Ocean apexStrange Animals Editorial · 16 references

Great white shark vs Orca

For decades the great white shark held the title of the ocean's apex predator. Then dead great whites began washing up on South African beaches with their livers missing: five carcasses near Gansbaai between February and June 2017, four of them without a liver. The killers were orcas. After those attacks, white sharks fled aggregation sites such as Gansbaai and Mossel Bay.

Great white sharkCarcharodon carcharias
Adult weightUp to about 2,000 kg
Body lengthUp to about 6.4 m
Top speedBursts to about 23 km/h (tagged sharks)
Bite force (est.)About 18,000 N (largest sharks)
TeethLarge, triangular, serrated
Brain sizeAbout 35 g (one specimen)
Social structureSolitary
SensesElectroreception, smell
Lifespan70+ years
IUCN statusVulnerable
VS
OrcaOrcinus orca
Adult male weightUp to about 10,000 kg (largest recorded)
Body lengthUp to 9.8 m
Top speedAbout 55 km/h (record burst)
Teeth40 to 56 conical, about 7.6 cm
Brain sizeAbout 5,600 g (largest of any dolphin)
Social structurePods of 2 to 15 related animals
SensesEcholocation, hearing
LifespanAbout 30 (males) to 50 (females) years, up to 90
IUCN statusData Deficient

Great White Shark vs Orca: head-to-head breakdown

Orca figures are maximums recorded for adult males; great white figures are adult maximums (females are the larger sex). The advantage column shows the measurable edge, and the orca holds it in almost every row.

1Great white edges
0Even
7Orca edges
Up to about 2,000 kg
Mass
Up to about 10,000 kg
5x
Up to about 6.4 m
Length
Up to 9.8 m
About 23 km/h burst
Top speed
About 55 km/h burst
2x
About 35 g
Brain
About 5.6 kg, largest of any dolphin
Solitary
Coordination
Pods of 2 to 15
Gills, stays submerged
Breathing
Lungs, must surface
Tonic immobility when inverted
Tonic immobility
Attempts to invert sharks
Large, fat-rich liver
Liver targeting
Precision bite to pectoral area

The liver-extraction technique

In South African waters, orcas attempt to roll great whites onto their backs, a position that can trigger tonic immobility, a reflex stillness sharks enter when inverted. The orca then bites at the pectoral area and takes the liver, which is large and rich in fat. The rest of the carcass is left behind.

Five white shark carcasses washed up near Gansbaai between February and June 2017, four with their livers removed; by mid-2022 eight such carcasses had been found on South Africa's coast. The wounds told the same story: missing livers, and in some cases missing hearts. White shark sightings at Gansbaai dropped sharply and tagged sharks left the area, a flight response the researchers link to orca presence.

Why the shark can't defend

Sharks are built for ambush: a hidden approach and one devastating strike, backed by a bite modelled at about 18,000 N in the largest great whites. That plan works on seals. It fails against a hunter that is several times heavier, more than twice as fast in a burst, and arrives as a team.

The orca brings a brain of about 5.6 kg, the largest of any dolphin, against the shark's 35 g, and it lives in pods of 2 to 15 related animals. Off Mossel Bay in 2022, five killer whales hunted white sharks together for about 71 minutes.

“Initially, following an Orca attack in Gansbaai, individual Great White Sharks did not appear for weeks or months. What we seem to be witnessing though is a large-scale avoidance (rather than a fine-scale) strategy, ... The more the Orcas frequent these sites, the longer the Great White Sharks stay away.”
Alison Towner, lead author of Fear at the top (African Journal of Marine Science, 2022), quoted by ScienceDaily

Documented encounters

Shark vs orca is no thought experiment: researchers have documented the hunts off California and South Africa, and the pattern holds. When orcas hunt great whites, the sharks die or leave.

01Farallon Islands, 1997On 4 October 1997 at Southeast Farallon Island, a pair of female killer whales attacked and ate a white shark, the first time this was documented. The white sharks then left the area.Orca won
02Gansbaai, South Africa, 2017A pair of killer whales nicknamed Port and Starboard began killing white sharks off Gansbaai. Five carcasses washed up between February and June 2017, four with their livers removed, and the sharks left the aggregation site.Orca won (repeatedly)
03Mossel Bay, 2022On 16 May 2022 off Hartenbos, Mossel Bay, a drone filmed five killer whales hunting white sharks for about 71 minutes, the first confirmed observation of a group of killer whales killing a white shark. At least two sharks died.Orca won
04The aftermath at GansbaaiAfter orca attacks, individual great whites stayed away from Gansbaai for weeks or months, and the more often the orcas returned, the longer the sharks stayed away.Sharks gave up the site
THE HONEST VERDICTOrca wins decisively. Where orcas hunt great whites, the sharks die or abandon the area.

This one is not close. The orca is several times the shark's mass, more than twice as fast in a burst, hunts in coordinated pods, and uses a technique aimed straight at the great white's weak point: roll it over, take the liver. The shark has no counter.

Its only advantage is that it never needs to surface, and depth is no refuge either: orcas have been recorded diving to 1,087 metres. Where orcas start hunting great whites, the sharks do the one thing left to them. They leave.

References

  1. Towner, A. V., Kock, A. A., Stopforth, C., Hurwitz, D., & Elwen, S. H. (2023). Direct observation of killer whales preying on white sharks and evidence of a flight response. Ecology, 104(1), e3875.
  2. Towner, A. V., et al. (2022). Fear at the top: killer whale predation drives white shark absence at South Africa's largest aggregation site. African Journal of Marine Science, 44(2), 139-152.
  3. Pyle, P., Schramm, M. J., Keiper, C., & Anderson, S. D. (1999). Predation on a white shark (Carcharodon carcharias) by a killer whale (Orcinus orca) and a possible case of competitive displacement of white sharks. Marine Mammal Science, 15(2), 563-568.
  4. Jorgensen, S. J., et al. (2019). Killer whales redistribute white shark foraging pressure on seals. Scientific Reports, 9, 6153.
  5. Wroe, S., et al. (2008). Three-dimensional computer analysis of white shark jaw mechanics: how hard can a great white bite? Journal of Zoology, 276(4), 336-342.
  6. Semmens, J. M., et al. (2019). Preparing to launch: biologging reveals the dynamics of white shark breaching behaviour. Marine Biology.
  7. ScienceDaily (30 June 2022). The pair of Orcas deterring Great White Sharks.
  8. Natural History Museum, London (2022). News report on killer whales hunting great white sharks.
  9. NOAA Fisheries. White shark and Killer whale species pages.
  10. SeaWorld Parks. Killer whale characteristics.
  11. Encyclopaedia Britannica. Killer whale.
  12. Martin, R. A. Structure and function of the white shark brain. ReefQuest Centre for Shark Research.
  13. Florida Museum of Natural History. Carcharodon carcharias species profile.
  14. UBC Marine Mammal Research Unit. Killer whale swimming speed record.
  15. Deakin University. Killer whales diving to record depths for dinner (Towers et al.).
  16. IUCN Red List. Carcharodon carcharias (Rigby et al., 2022) and Orcinus orca assessments.
SPECIES PROFILEGreat white shark: full species profile, including why orcas hunt themOpen →
SPECIES PROFILEOrca: full species profile, including why it hunts great whitesOpen →