Yellowstone heavyweightsStrange Animals Editorial · 6 references

American bison vs Grizzly bear

Bison and grizzly bears share the same Yellowstone valleys. The bison is North America's heaviest land animal: a bull can weigh about 900 kg. The grizzly is the continent's most powerful land predator, and some large males hunt adult bison in early spring. Here is what the measurements and the Park Service record actually show.

American bisonBison bison
Adult bull weightUp to about 900 kg
Adult cow weightAbout 500 kg
Shoulder height1.7 to 1.8 m (bulls)
Body length3.0 to 3.8 m
Top speed55 km/h
HornsAbout 36 cm (bulls), both sexes
Herd sizeAbout 20 in winter, up to 1,000 in the rut
DietGrazer (grass, sedge)
Lifespan (wild)12 to 15 years, a few to 20
IUCN statusNear Threatened
VS
Grizzly bearUrsus arctos horribilis
Adult male weight187 kg average, 324 kg max (Yellowstone)
Shoulder heightAbout 1 m
Top speed56 to 64 km/h
Claws4.5 cm average, up to 15 cm
Bite force (est.)About 750 N, canine
Social structureMostly solitary
DietOmnivore that also hunts
Lifespan (wild)20 to 30 years
IUCN statusLeast Concern (global)

Bison vs Grizzly Bear: head-to-head breakdown

Figures come from the US National Park Service in Yellowstone and published bite-force models. The advantage column shows the measurable edge, not the winner of any single encounter.

2Bison edges
2Even
2Grizzly edges
4 to 5x
Up to about 900 kg
Mass
187 kg average
55 km/h
Top speed
56 to 64 km/h
Horns + charging mass
Primary weapon
Claws + bite
No (grazer)
Hunts other animals
Yes, including bison
Herds, often around 20
Group defence
Mostly solitary
12 to 15 years
Lifespan (wild)
20 to 30 years

Why mass is the bison's whole case

A mature bull can weigh four to five times what an average Yellowstone male grizzly does, and that is the single most important number on this page. A bison fights from the front, head down, with horns about 36 cm long and a dense shoulder hump behind them. And bison rarely stand alone: winter groups in Yellowstone average about 20 animals.

Why the grizzly is still the predator

Mass matters less when only one animal is hunting. The bison is a grazer; the grizzly is an omnivore that also kills large prey. In Yellowstone some large male grizzlies prey on adult bison during early spring, when winter has left many animals weak, and bears hunt elk calves into midsummer.

“Wolves and grizzly bears can kill adult bison, but predation has little effect on the bison population.”
US National Park Service, Yellowstone bison

Documented encounters

Unlike most matchups, bison and grizzlies meet constantly. Yellowstone is the natural laboratory, and decades of observation show most encounters end with no fight at all.

01Early springThe season the Park Service names for grizzly predation on adult bison, when winter has weakened many animals.Grizzly's best chance
02Calf in the herdA calf is the easiest target, but it sits inside a herd that can number around 20 or more.Depends on the herd
03Healthy bull, head-onFour to five times the bear's average weight, horns forward. This is the bison's strongest position.Bison favoured
04Whole populationPredation by wolves and grizzlies has little effect on Yellowstone's bison numbers.Bison hold their own
THE HONEST VERDICTA grizzly can kill a bison when the season and the animal are weak. A healthy bull outweighs it four to five times.

This matchup splits by circumstance. A grizzly can and does kill adult bison, mostly in early spring when the bison are at their weakest.

A healthy bull is a different animal: four to five times the bear's average weight, armed with horns and usually backed by a herd. Across the whole population, predation barely dents bison numbers.

References

  1. US National Park Service. Bison ecology and Bison facts and figures. Yellowstone National Park.
  2. US National Park Service. Yellowstone grizzly bear facts; Bear food habits. Yellowstone National Park.
  3. Wroe, S., McHenry, C., & Thomason, J. (2005). Bite club: comparative bite force in big biting mammals. Proceedings of the Royal Society B, 272(1563), 619-625.
  4. Meagher, M. (1986). Bison bison. Mammalian Species, No. 266, 1-8.
  5. Gunther, K. A., et al. (2014). Dietary breadth of grizzly bears in the Greater Yellowstone Ecosystem. Ursus, 25(1), 60-72.
  6. IUCN Red List. Bison bison and Ursus arctos assessments.