Worst stingStrange Animals Editorial · 11 references

Bullet ant vs Asian giant hornet

Two insects, two very different ways to ruin your day. The bullet ant carries the sting Justin Schmidt rated 4 on his Sting Pain Index, the top of the scale, and in his original 1983 index it was the only sting to reach that level. The Asian giant hornet is the world's largest hornet: it stings repeatedly, injects about 10 times the venom of a honeybee, and a mass attack can kill. One delivers the worst pain; the other the worst danger.

Bullet antParaponera clavata
Schmidt pain rating4 (top of the scale)
Primary venom toxinPoneratoxin
RangeCentral and South America
Colony size200 to 3,000 workers
ForagingUnderstory and canopy
Rite of passageSateré-Mawé glove ordeal
Nickname24-hour ant
VS
Asian giant hornetVespa mandarinia
Body lengthAbout 40 mm (workers), queens near 50 mm
Schmidt pain ratingNot rated by Schmidt
Primary venom toxinMandaratoxin and others
Venom per stingAbout 10x a honeybee's
Delivery6 mm barbless stinger, repeated
Lethal to humansYes, in mass attacks
Japan sting deathsAbout 17 a year, all wasps and bees
RangeEast, South and Southeast Asia
NicknameMurder hornet

Bullet Ant vs Asian Giant Hornet: head-to-head breakdown

These two are judged on different scales, so advantage here means which insect is more extreme in each category, not which would win a fight. Pain uses Justin Schmidt's index; danger uses venom load and what a sting can do to a person.

1Bullet ant edges
3Even
2Hornet edges
4, top of the index
Schmidt pain rating
Not rated by Schmidt
Poneratoxin
Main toxin
Mandaratoxin and others
Extreme pain
Danger to humans
Mass stings can kill
Forages understory and canopy
Mobility
Flying hunter
Central and South America
Range
East, South and Southeast Asia
24-hour ant
Nickname
Murder hornet

Why the bullet ant owns the pain crown

Entomologist Justin Schmidt rated the bullet ant's sting a 4, the top of his Sting Pain Index, and in his original 1983 index it was the only sting to reach that level. He described it as "pure, intense, brilliant pain, like walking over flaming charcoal with a 3-inch nail embedded in your heel." Locals call it the 24-hour ant.

The key ingredient is poneratoxin, a neurotoxic peptide. Colonies hold 200 to 3,000 workers that forage from the forest understory up into the canopy. In the Sateré-Mawé initiation rite in Brazil, young men wear gloves lined with these ants, and a man is expected to go through the ordeal at least 20 times in his life.

Why the hornet is the one that can kill you

Vespa mandarinia is the world's largest hornet: workers are about 40 mm long and queens close to 50 mm. Its 6 mm barbless stinger goes through regular beekeeping suits, it can sting repeatedly, and it delivers about 10 times the venom of a honeybee. Its mandaratoxin is a neurotoxin that acts on the nerves.

Dose is what makes it dangerous. A mass attack can kill even people with no allergy, through sheer venom load and kidney failure. In Japan, 191 people died after wasp and bee stings of all kinds between 2008 and 2018, an average of about 17 a year.

Where each one wins

These two never meet in nature: one lives in Central and South American rainforest, the other across East, South and Southeast Asia. So here's how each wins, depending on what you're afraid of.

01The worst pain of your lifeFor raw agony from one sting, the bullet ant is the benchmark: a 4, the top of Schmidt's index, and the only sting rated that high in his original 1983 list.Bullet ant wins
02The sting that hospitalises youFor medical danger the hornet wins decisively. About 10 times a honeybee's venom per sting, repeated stings and, in a mass attack, organ failure even without an allergy.Hornet wins
03Through protective gearA 6 mm stinger that goes through regular beekeeping suits means standard protection is not enough against the hornet.Hornet wins
04A rite of passageThe Sateré-Mawé glove ordeal, repeated at least 20 times in a man's life, has turned the bullet ant's sting into a test of courage.Bullet ant's legend
THE HONEST VERDICTWorst pain: the bullet ant, a 4 at the top of Schmidt's index. Worst danger: the Asian giant hornet, whose mass stings can kill.

Both insects are champions, of different titles. If the question is which sting hurts most, it's settled: Justin Schmidt rated the bullet ant a 4, the top of his index, and in his original 1983 index it stood alone at that level. The hornet has no rating from Schmidt at all, because he has never been stung by one.

If the question is which insect to actually fear, the Asian giant hornet wins without argument. It is the world's largest hornet, it stings repeatedly through beekeeping suits, it injects about 10 times a honeybee's venom, and a mass attack can kill.

References

  1. Schmidt, J. O. (2016). The Sting of the Wild. Johns Hopkins University Press.
  2. Schmidt, J. O., Blum, M. S., & Overal, W. L. (1983). Hemolytic activities of stinging insect venoms. Archives of Insect Biochemistry and Physiology, 1(2), 155-160.
  3. Szolajska, E., et al. (2004). Poneratoxin, a neurotoxin from ant venom. Structure and expression in insect cells and construction of a bio-insecticide. European Journal of Biochemistry, 271(11), 2127-2136.
  4. Abe, T., et al. (1982). Purification and properties of a presynaptically acting neurotoxin, mandaratoxin, from hornet (Vespa mandarinia). Biochemistry, 21(7), 1693-1697.
  5. Yanagawa, Y., Morita, K., Sugiura, T., & Okada, Y. (2007). Cutaneous hemorrhage or necrosis findings after Vespa mandarinia (wasp) stings may predict the occurrence of multiple organ injury: a case report and review of literature. Clinical Toxicology, 45(7), 803-807.
  6. Matsuura, M., & Yamane, S. (1990). Biology of the Vespine Wasps. Springer-Verlag.
  7. Oregon State University Extension Service. Northern giant hornet, EM 9297. University of Florida IFAS Extension, EDIS IN1281.
  8. National Geographic (2020). How murder hornet stings compare.
  9. Japan Ministry of Health, Labour and Welfare vital statistics on wasp and bee sting deaths, 2008 to 2018, as reported by Nippon.com.
  10. Dyer, field study of Paraponera clavata in Costa Rica and Panama, citing Breed and Harrison (1988).
  11. Mongabay (2019). Reporting on the Sateré-Mawé bullet ant rite, with the Pulitzer Center.