Are hyenas related to dogs or cats?
Spotted hyenas are more closely related to cats than dogs, despite their dog-like appearance. Hyenas belong to the family Hyaenidae in the suborder Feliformia (cat-like carnivores), which also includes cats, mongooses and civets. Dogs belong to the suborder Caniformia (dog-like carnivores) along with bears, raccoons and weasels. The two lineages diverged more than 40 million years ago.
The Misunderstood Matriarchs
Walt Disney's Lion King portrayed hyenas as cowardly scavengers. Colonial-era naturalists described them as lazy bone-eaters. Popular culture consistently depicts them as villains of the African savanna: the animal that cheats, steals and lacks the nobility of "proper" predators.
Nearly all of this is wrong. Spotted hyenas are skilled hunters that kill most of their own food, live in female-dominated matriarchal societies, have bone-crushing jaws and display social intelligence rivaling primates. The animals actually caught scavenging from hyena kills are often lions, the reverse of the popular narrative.
The Hyena Family
Four species of hyena exist:
- Spotted hyena (Crocuta crocuta): largest and most numerous
- Brown hyena (Hyaena brunnea): southern Africa, more scavenger
- Striped hyena (Hyaena hyaena): North Africa, Middle East, India
- Aardwolf (Proteles cristata): small insectivore specialized on termites
Taxonomic surprise:
Hyenas may look dog-like, but they are more closely related to cats than dogs. They sit in the feline branch of carnivore evolutionary history. The resemblance to dogs came from convergent evolution: both filled similar ecological niches that produced similar body plans in unrelated lineages.
Female Dominance
Spotted hyenas are notable for female-dominated society, inverted from typical mammalian patterns.
Size difference:
- Females: 10-15 percent larger than males
- Female weight: 55 to over 70 kg
- Male weight: 45-60 kg
- Females more aggressive and dominant
Social structure:
Hyena clans are matriarchal:
- Dominant female (matriarch) leads
- All females rank above all males
- Female offspring inherit mother's rank
- Males leave natal clans, females stay
This is opposite to lion prides, wolf packs and most mammalian societies where males dominate.
Why this evolved:
Several hypotheses attempt to explain female dominance:
Food competition: High aggression evolved to ensure cubs get enough food during chaotic feeding at kills.
High testosterone. Female hyena fetuses encounter unusually high androgen levels, which results in larger body size and more aggressive disposition.
Cub protection. Dominant mothers do a better job defending vulnerable cubs from infanticide.
Inheritance advantage: Ranks inherited from mothers create stable matriline hierarchies.
The exact evolutionary explanation remains debated.
How tall is a spotted hyena?
An adult spotted hyena stands about 75 to 85 cm (30 to 33 in) at the shoulder. Measured from the head to the tip of the tail, the body runs roughly 95 to 150 cm (37 to 59 in). Females are the heavier sex, weighing 55 to over 70 kg (121 to over 154 lb) against roughly 45 to 60 kg (99 to 132 lb) for males.
Is a spotted hyena bigger than a wolf?
The two are close in size, and the answer depends on which sex is compared. Gray wolves stand about 60 to 90 cm (24 to 35 in) at the shoulder, a range that brackets the spotted hyena's 75 to 85 cm (30 to 33 in). By weight, a female spotted hyena at 55 to over 70 kg (121 to over 154 lb) is heavier than an average female wolf of about 45 kg (99 lb).
Male wolves vary far more than hyenas. They weigh 30 to 80 kg (66 to 176 lb) with an average of about 55 kg (121 lb), so the largest wolves outweigh any male hyena, which tops out near 60 kg (132 lb).
Unusual Anatomy
Female hyena genitals are anatomically unique among mammals.
The pseudo-penis:
Female spotted hyenas have:
- Enlarged clitoris resembling a penis
- Fused labia forming a scrotum-like structure
- No external vaginal opening
- Urination, mating and birth all through the clitoral tube
Reproductive challenges:
This anatomy makes reproduction unusually dangerous:
- Mating requires special male positioning
- Birth canal passes through the pseudo-penis
- Up to 10 percent of first-time mothers die during birth
- Newborn cubs often damage the birth canal
Despite risks, the anatomy persists, presumably because associated traits (aggression, female dominance) provide overriding evolutionary benefits.
How does a female spotted hyena give birth?
A female spotted hyena has no external vagina, so she delivers her cubs through the urogenital canal that runs the length of her enlarged clitoris. After a pregnancy of about 110 days, usually producing twins, the cubs must pass through this narrow, elongated passage. During the first birth the clitoris stretches and tears to let the young through, and later births are far easier because of that first rupture.
The cost falls hardest on first litters. Research by Laurence Frank, Mary Weldele and Stephen Glickman at the University of California, Berkeley found that up to 10 percent of first-time mothers and over 60 percent of first-born young die during birth.
Hunting, Not Scavenging
Spotted hyenas are primarily hunters.
Hunting statistics:
- At least half, and up to 98 percent of food comes from their own kills, depending on the population
- The remainder comes from scavenging
- In studied areas, hyenas hunt as much as lions do
Prey:
- Wildebeest
- Zebras
- Thomson's gazelles
- Topi
- Occasionally Cape buffalo
Hunting technique:
Spotted hyenas hunt cooperatively:
- Clan members locate prey
- Chase begins, often over long distances
- Prey runs to exhaustion
- Multiple hyenas attack simultaneously
- Kill is typically fast after takedown
Reversing the myth:
Studies in hyena-lion coexistence areas show that lions frequently scavenge hyena kills instead. Hyenas either leave or stay at a distance when lions confront them on a kill.
Laughter and Communication
Hyena vocalizations are complex and information-rich.
The laugh:
Hyenas produce their famous "laugh" as a stress vocalization, not humor. When hyenas laugh, it is because:
- Excited during feeding
- Submitting to higher-ranked individuals
- Frustrated during competition
- Uncertain about social situations
Information encoded:
Research shows laugh structure varies with:
- Age of the individual
- Social rank
- Current emotional state
- Sex
Listeners can identify specific individuals from laugh patterns alone.
Other vocalizations:
Hyenas produce a wide variety of sounds:
- Whoops: long-distance contact calls
- Groans: close-range social signals
- Grunts: greeting and bonding
- Yells: alarm or pain
- Whines: subordinate communication
- Giggles: the trademark laugh, linked to fear or excitement
- Various other calls
The Bone-Crushing Bite
Spotted hyenas have among the strongest bite force of any mammal.
One published estimate puts the spotted hyena's bite pressure at about 80 kgf/cm2, roughly 1,140 PSI.
What this enables:
Hyenas crush most bones with ease. Skulls, femurs, ribs all break under hyena jaws. This capability allows hyenas to consume parts of carcasses that other predators do not touch.
Bone digestion:
Hyena stomach acid dissolves bone, which allows hyenas to extract nutrition other carnivores cannot access.
Distinctive droppings:
Hyenas excrete bright white feces because their digestive tracts do not absorb calcium carbonate. Across African savannas, the distinctive pale droppings mark hyena territory.
Ecological role:
This bone-crushing ability gives hyenas a unique position in African ecosystems. They extract nutrition from carcasses that would otherwise rot, recycling calcium and other minerals back into the food web.
Clan Life
Hyena clans are complex social organizations.
Size:
Clans range from about 3 to 80 individuals depending on prey availability and habitat. Spotted hyenas have the largest group sizes of any carnivoran.
Territory:
Clans defend territories ranging from about 40 to 1,000 square kilometers. Boundaries are marked with scent and defended aggressively against neighboring clans.
Communal dens:
Every clan mother uses communal dens for cub rearing. Multiple females occupy the same den, but each mother nurses only her own cubs.
Cub development:
- Born with eyes open and with canines and incisors already erupted
- Siblicidal within first weeks (first-born often kills weaker sibling)
- Nursed exclusively (no milk sharing among females)
- Weaned at 12-16 months
Social learning:
Hunting, social rules and clan knowledge are taught to cubs by mothers and other female relatives. When they reach maturity, young males disperse to join other clans.
Conflicts with Lions
Hyena-lion conflicts are common in areas where both species live.
Competition:
Both are apex predators competing for similar prey and territory. Interactions are frequent and often violent.
Outcomes:
- Lions typically kill lone hyenas they catch
- Large hyena clans can steal kills from smaller lion groups
- Adult male lions dominate in one-on-one encounters
- Hyena clans can drive off single male lions through numbers
Infanticide:
Both species kill each other's young when opportunities arise:
- Lions kill hyena cubs at dens when found
- Hyenas kill lion cubs similarly
- This kill-and-replace pattern reduces competition
Coexistence:
Despite conflicts, both species coexist across much of Africa. Competition is balanced enough that neither eliminates the other.
Conservation
Spotted hyenas face various threats.
Population:
Estimated 27,000-47,000 spotted hyenas remain in Africa. Populations are stable in protected areas but declining overall.
Threats:
- Persecution: farmers kill hyenas for attacking livestock
- Poisoning: cyanide baits target predators including hyenas
- Traffic collisions: roads through habitat cause deaths
- Habitat loss: agricultural expansion reduces territory
- Disease: susceptibility to diseases spread from domestic dogs
Cultural persecution:
In certain areas, negative cultural views of hyenas as evil, scavengers and supernatural beings drive targeted killings. Conservation education seeks to address and correct these misconceptions.
Why the Myth Persists
Hyenas continue to be depicted inaccurately in popular culture despite decades of corrective scientific research.
The reasons include:
- Disney's Lion King influenced generations
- Early naturalists' biased reports entered cultural narrative
- Hyenas' unusual appearance and vocalizations seem "wrong" to human aesthetics
- Their female-dominated society challenges assumptions
- Their eating habits are visible (scavenging occurs in open areas) while their hunting is less observed
Real hyenas are nothing like their cultural image. They are intelligent, social, skilled hunters led by matriarchs in complex clans. They crush bone, run down prey cooperatively and communicate with a wide range of vocalizations.
A hyena on the African savanna is not a lesser predator. It is a different kind of predator: one that ecological research has increasingly come to respect even as popular culture continues misrepresenting them.
Hyena Social Cognition
Kay Holekamp's long-term field study of Masai Mara spotted hyenas has produced much of what is known about their social cognition.
In a separate 2009 study published in Animal Behaviour, researchers from Duke University and the University of California, Berkeley showed that pairs of captive hyenas could coordinate their actions to solve a cooperative rope-pulling task. Chimpanzees were not tested in that study, but primates confronted with similar tasks have often required extensive training [1].
Holekamp's team has also shown that, as in cercopithecine primates, spotted hyenas recognize their kin and other clan members as individuals, recognize third-party kin and rank relationships among their clan mates, and use this knowledge in social decision making [2].
Hyena Social Complexity
| Feature | Spotted hyena | Chimpanzee | Lion |
|---|---|---|---|
| Clan/group size | 3-80 | 15-150 | 2-20 (pride) |
| Rank inheritance | Yes (maternal) | Yes (maternal influence) | No stable ranks |
| Cooperative hunting | Yes (coordinated) | Yes (occasional) | Yes |
| Vocal individual recognition | Yes (laugh patterns) | Yes (pant hoots) | Partial |
| Greeting ceremonies | Elaborate (genital display) | Kiss, embrace | Head rub, tail flick |
| Multi-year alliances | Yes | Yes | Limited |
| Female dominance | Strict | No (male dominant) | Complex |
Hormonal Biology and the Androgen Puzzle
One of the most studied aspects of spotted hyena biology is the unusual hormone profile. Female spotted hyenas are exposed to high levels of androstenedione during fetal development. This androgen is produced by the mother's ovaries and converted to testosterone in the placenta. The result is prenatal masculinization of female external genitalia and, apparently, of adult aggressive behavior.
A long-running research program at the University of California Berkeley under Stephen Glickman and Laurence Frank studied captive spotted hyena colonies to investigate this phenomenon [3].
Conservation Status Across the Four Species
Hyaenidae Family Status
| Species | IUCN status | Estimated population | Trend | Primary threats |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Spotted hyena | Least Concern | 27,000-47,000 | Declining | Persecution, poisoning |
| Brown hyena | Near Threatened | <10,000 | Stable to declining | Habitat loss, persecution |
| Striped hyena | Near Threatened | <10,000 | Declining | Persecution, road mortality |
| Aardwolf | Least Concern | Unknown (stable) | Stable | Pesticides (affect termites) |
Spotted hyena populations are declining outside protected areas because of habitat loss and poaching. Striped hyenas have the most widespread range (North Africa through the Middle East to India) but exist at low densities everywhere and are persecuted in many regions due to associations with graveyards and superstition.
Notable Research Findings
- Spotted hyenas have an exceptionally powerful bite, producing pressures sufficient to crack the long bones of giraffes. Their digestive system can dissolve the calcium matrix of bones entirely.
- Spotted hyenas can chase prey at up to 60 km/h over distances of several kilometres. They are endurance predators, wearing prey down over long chases rather than catching them in short sprints.
- Cubs nurse from their mothers for 12-16 months, although they can process solid food from about three months. Spotted hyena milk has the highest protein and fat content of any terrestrial carnivore.
- Spotted hyenas have been observed following wild dogs at kills, taking advantage of the dogs' hunting efficiency.
- In several Ethiopian cities, including Harar, spotted hyenas enter urban areas nightly to feed on human food waste. In Harar, residents regularly feed the hyenas and traditional "hyena men" hand-feed them scraps.
Frequently asked questions
Hyenas are more closely related to cats than dogs, despite their dog-like appearance. Hyenas belong to the family Hyaenidae in the suborder Feliformia (cat-like carnivores), which also includes cats, mongooses and civets. Dogs belong to the suborder Caniformia (dog-like carnivores) along with bears, raccoons and weasels. The two lineages diverged more than 40 million years ago.
Hyenas’ dog-like appearance is convergent evolution: similar ecological niches producing similar body plans in unrelated lineages. Four hyena species exist: the spotted hyena (Crocuta crocuta), brown hyena (Hyaena brunnea), striped hyena (Hyaena hyaena), and aardwolf (Proteles cristata). The spotted hyena is the largest and most numerous species.
The aardwolf is a small insectivore specialized on termites, very different from other hyenas.
Spotted hyena females are 10-15 percent larger than males and dominate their societies, a reversal of the typical mammalian pattern where males dominate. All females rank above all males. Evolutionary biologists debate the reasons. One hypothesis is that high aggression evolved to ensure cubs get enough food during chaotic feeding at kills.
Another involves high androgen exposure in female fetuses, producing larger bodies and more aggressive personalities. Female hyenas have unusually masculinized genitalia, including an enlarged clitoris that resembles a penis: they urinate, mate and give birth through this structure.
This anatomy makes reproduction unusually dangerous: up to 10 percent of first-time mothers die during birth. Female offspring inherit their mother’s rank, creating stable matriline hierarchies.
Spotted hyena ‘laughter’ is a stress vocalization, not humor. Hyenas laugh when excited during feeding, when submitting to higher-ranked individuals, when frustrated during competition and when uncertain about social situations.
Research shows the structure of the laugh varies with the hyena’s age, social rank, sex and current emotional state, and listeners can identify specific individuals from laugh patterns alone.
Hyenas also produce other vocalizations including whoops (long-distance contact calls), groans, grunts, whines and yells.
Spotted hyenas are hunters first, not scavengers, contrary to widespread belief. Populations vary, but at least half and up to 98 percent of their food comes from kills they make themselves, with the rest scavenged. They chase prey cooperatively over long distances until the target runs exhausted, then they attack together.
Hyenas take down wildebeest, zebras, Thomson’s gazelles, topi and occasionally Cape buffalo. In regions where hyenas and lions coexist, lions often scavenge hyena kills instead of the other way around.
Colonial-era naturalists and popular culture propagated the myth that hyenas were cowardly scavengers. Studies have shown that in monitored areas, hyenas hunt as much as lions.
Spotted hyenas have among the strongest bite force of any mammal. One published estimate puts their bite pressure at about 80 kgf/cm2, roughly 1,140 PSI, enough to crack the long bones of giraffes.
Their powerful jaws let them crush skull, femur and rib bones that other predators leave behind. Hyena stomach acid dissolves bone, letting hyenas extract nutrition unavailable to other carnivores.
The bone diet produces distinctive bright white droppings, colored by undigested calcium carbonate. These pale droppings are visible across African savannas and indicate hyena territory.
References
- Drea, C. M., & Carter, A. N. (2009). Cooperative problem solving in a social carnivore. Animal Behaviour, 78(4), 967-977. View source
- Holekamp, K. E., Sakai, S. T., & Lundrigan, B. L. (2007). Social intelligence in the spotted hyena (Crocuta crocuta). Philosophical Transactions of the Royal Society B, 362(1480), 523-538. View source
- Glickman, S. E., Cunha, G. R., Drea, C. M., Conley, A. J., & Place, N. J. (2006). Mammalian sexual differentiation: Lessons from the spotted hyena. Trends in Endocrinology and Metabolism, 17(9), 349-356. View source
- Kruuk, H. (1972). The Spotted Hyena: A Study of Predation and Social Behavior. University of Chicago Press.
- Watts, H. E., & Holekamp, K. E. (2007). Hyena societies. Current Biology, 17(16), R657-R660. View source
- Frank, L. G., Glickman, S. E., & Powch, I. (1990). Sexual dimorphism in the spotted hyena (Crocuta crocuta). Journal of Zoology, 221(2), 308-313.
- Animal Diversity Web. Crocuta crocuta (spotted hyena). University of Michigan Museum of Zoology. View source
- Animal Diversity Web. Canis lupus (gray wolf). University of Michigan Museum of Zoology. View source
- University of California, Berkeley. (1995, November 1). Extraordinary births. Berkeleyan. View source