How many subspecies of brown bear are there?

Taxonomists have historically proposed as many as 90 brown bear subspecies of Ursus arctos , and a 2005 compilation recognised 15, though modern DNA research has found as few as five main mitochondrial clades.

The commonly recognised living forms are the Eurasian brown bear ( U. a. arctos ), the North American grizzly ( U. a. horribilis ), the Kodiak bear ( U. a. middendorffi ), the Syrian brown bear ( U. a. syriacus ), the Himalayan brown bear ( U. a. isabellinus ), the Gobi bear ( U. a. gobiensis ), and the Tibetan blue bear ( U. a. pruinosus ). Two subspecies, the Atlas bear and the California grizzly, are extinct.


One Species, One Hemisphere, Dozens of Names

There is a single brown bear species on Earth. Its scientific name is Ursus arctos , and it is the most widely distributed bear in the world, ranging from the coastal rainforests of southeast Alaska to the arid mountain steppe of Mongolia. Every bear commonly called a grizzly, a Kodiak, a Kamchatka bear, a Marsican bear, or a blue bear is the same species.

What varies is the subspecies: the regional form, shaped by isolation, climate and diet, and given a trinomial Latin name by whichever 19th or 20th century zoologist happened to describe it first.

For a general overview of the species itself, see the main page on the brown bear . This article focuses on the deeper question of what the subspecies actually are, how many of them hold up under modern genetics, and why names you may still see in older field guides, Dall bear, Peninsular grizzly, Shirās grizzly, Admiralty Island brown bear, have quietly disappeared from the scientific literature.

The short version is that most of the as many as 90 subspecies names proposed are no longer valid . Modern molecular work has collapsed them into a handful of genetically coherent lineages. The long version is more interesting, because it includes a critically endangered desert bear with a population of about 30, a North African subspecies hunted to extinction in the 1800s, and DNA evidence that polar bears are technically nested inside the brown bear family tree.


The Historic Subspecies

Below is the traditional list of named brown bear subspecies that appears in most field guides published before the genomic era. Some of these are still widely used, others survive only as historical labels.

Subspecies Common name Range Status
U. a. arctos Eurasian brown bear Europe, Russia, western Asia Widespread
U. a. horribilis Grizzly bear North America (interior) Valid, Threatened in US
U. a. middendorffi Kodiak bear Kodiak Archipelago, Alaska Valid, isolated
U. a. sitkensis ABC Islands brown bear Admiralty, Baranof, Chichagof Disputed (genetics near polar)
U. a. dalli Dall Island brown bear Dall Island, Alaska Not widely recognised
U. a. gyas Peninsular giant bear Alaska Peninsula Questionably distinct
U. a. syriacus Syrian brown bear Middle East, Caucasus, Iran Valid, fragmented
U. a. isabellinus Himalayan brown bear Western Himalayas Valid, Critically Endangered
U. a. pruinosus Tibetan blue bear Tibetan plateau Valid, rarely observed
U. a. gobiensis Gobi bear (mazaalai) Mongolian Gobi desert Valid, Critically Endangered
U. a. lasiotus Ussuri brown bear Russian Far East, NE China, Hokkaido Sometimes retained
U. a. beringianus Kamchatka brown bear Kamchatka Peninsula Sometimes retained
U. a. collaris East Siberian brown bear Siberia east of Yenisey Sometimes retained
U. a. crowtheri Atlas bear North Africa Extinct (c. 1870)
U. a. californicus California grizzly California Extinct (1924)

The pattern is striking. More than half of these names describe populations that were isolated by mountains, islands, or rivers for long enough that morphology diverged, but not long enough to leave a clear genetic signature. The few that have stood up to genomic scrutiny are those with deep isolation, such as the Kodiak bears, or those with unique ecology, such as the Gobi bear.


Why Modern Genetics Collapsed the List

The revolution came from mitochondrial DNA. Starting in the late 1990s and accelerating through the 2010s, researchers extracted DNA from museum skins, hunter samples, scat collections and live-caught bears across the species' range. They expected regional mitochondrial clades. What they found was messier and more interesting.

Mitochondrial DNA work has divided brown bears into roughly five major clades , some of which co-occur in the same regions. Examples include:

  • A western lineage: Iberia, southern Scandinavia, Italy and the Balkans
  • An eastern lineage: Russia, northern Scandinavia and eastern Europe
  • The ABC Islands of Alaska, whose bears carry polar bear mitochondrial DNA

This is why the old subspecies list quietly collapsed. The tree does not respect the labels: brown bears along the Alaska coast, for example, are more closely related to adjacent grizzlies than to distant coastal populations.

For a deeper comparison between the two most famous North American forms, the article brown bear vs grizzly bear walks through the specific morphological and dietary differences without getting lost in taxonomy.


The Eurasian Brown Bear (U. a. arctos)

The Eurasian brown bear is the nominate subspecies, the one Linnaeus described in 1758 when he coined Ursus arctos . It is also the most widespread. A single population extends, with interruptions, from the Cantabrian Mountains of Spain through the Carpathians, across European Russia, through Siberia and into the Russian Far East, where it grades into the Ussuri and Kamchatka forms.

Typical size. Highly variable. The largest Eurasian brown bear reportedly shot weighed 481 kg, and bears in Slovakia and Bulgaria have been weighed at up to 400 kg.

Strongholds:

  • Russia. Roughly 130,000 bears
  • Romania: 5,000-6,000
  • Slovakia and Slovenia. About 600-800 and 500-700 respectively
  • Spain (Cantabrian) and Italy (Marsican). About 210 and about 50 bears, small isolated populations

The Marsican or Apennine brown bear of Italy ( U. a. marsicanus to some authors) and the Cantabrian population of Spain are isolated populations now considered part of the nominate Eurasian subspecies. The Marsican population is believed to number only about 50 bears.

For a focused look at European populations, see European brown bear, where they live .


The North American Grizzly (U. a. horribilis)

The grizzly is the interior North American form, named horribilis by George Ord in 1815. In the contiguous United States, grizzlies now survive in only a small fraction of their former range.

Typical size (interior): males average about 180 kg and females about 135 kg. Coastal brown bears in Alaska, sometimes lumped into horribilis and sometimes not, weigh about twice as much.

Populations:

  • Alaska: ~30,000 (including coastal forms)
  • Canada: ~25,000
  • Contiguous US. Federally listed Threatened

For the detailed physiology and behaviour, the piece grizzly bear: North American predator covers it in full.


The Kodiak Bear (U. a. middendorffi)

The Kodiak bear is the giant. Isolated on the Kodiak Archipelago of southwest Alaska since the end of the last glaciation roughly 12,000 years ago, this subspecies has diverged in skull morphology and body mass to the point where it is clearly distinguishable on sight. Males weigh roughly 270-635 kg, the largest widely accepted wild Kodiak, killed in 1894, weighed 751 kg .

Kodiak bears are on average 1.5 to 2 times larger than mainland grizzlies, though coastal peninsular brown bears may rival them. They have been genetically isolated since at least the last ice age and have very little genetic diversity, although some authors treat them as an insular population of the grizzly subspecies. They feed heavily on five salmon species during the summer runs, supplemented by berries, grasses and the occasional deer. The archipelago, about 13,000 square kilometres, held an estimated 3,526 bears in 2005.

For the full profile, see Kodiak bear: the largest brown bear , and for a side-by-side with the grizzly, grizzly bear vs Kodiak bear .


The Syrian Brown Bear (U. a. syriacus)

The Syrian brown bear is a medium- to small-sized, pale subspecies. Adults reportedly weigh around 100-160 kg, and up to about 250 kg at most. The coat is light brown to straw coloured, and the claws are pale rather than the dark brown or black of most other forms.

The historical range stretched across the Levant, the Caucasus, Iraq, Iran, and parts of Anatolia. The Syrian brown bear has been extirpated from Israel, Jordan, and the Sinai Peninsula and is extremely rare or possibly absent in Syria and Lebanon. Modern populations persist in:

  • Turkey. The Black Sea region, northeast and eastern Anatolia
  • Iran. Mostly in the Alborz and Zagros mountains
  • Georgia, Armenia, Azerbaijan. The Caucasus
  • Iraq. Present

The Himalayan Brown Bear (U. a. isabellinus)

The Himalayan brown bear lives at high elevations in the western Himalaya. Its coat is a distinctive reddish-brown or sandy brown, often with silver-tipped hairs.

These are small bears by brown bear standards, averaging about 135 kg for males and 70 kg for females in Pakistan. They occur in Pakistan, northern India (Jammu and Kashmir, Himachal Pradesh, Uttarakhand) and Nepal. The population in northern Pakistan was estimated at about 150 to 200 individuals in 2007.

The Himalayan brown bear is also the likely source of many yeti reports. A 2017 study published in Proceedings of the Royal Society B analysed DNA from purported yeti samples, and a mummified animal said to be a yeti proved to be a Himalayan brown bear.


The Gobi Bear (U. a. gobiensis)

The Gobi bear, known locally as mazaalai , is the only bear that lives in a true desert. There may be fewer than 50 individuals, and a long-term genetic study published in 2021 estimated about 31 , surviving in oases of the Mongolian Gobi. It is classified Critically Endangered by the IUCN.

Metric Gobi bear (U. a. gobiensis)
Estimated population ~31 (2021 estimate)
Range Desert oases in the Mongolian Gobi
Male weight 96-138 kg
Female weight 51-78 kg
Coat Small and pale; appears to lack a pale collar
Diet Roots, berries, other plants, occasional rodents
IUCN status Critically Endangered

Gobi bears are small, pale and adapted to hyper-arid conditions. They do not rely on salmon or ungulate herds, their diet is mostly roots, berries and other plants, with occasional rodents. A supplemental feeding program, running since 1985, provides pellets at feeders near waterholes in spring and autumn.


The Tibetan Blue Bear (U. a. pruinosus)

The Tibetan blue bear lives on the Tibetan plateau. Despite the name, it is not actually blue, the coat varies from dark to light, and the fur around the neck, chest and shoulders is usually yellowish-brown or whitish, often forming a collar.


The Extinct Subspecies

Two subspecies of Ursus arctos were driven to extinction in historical times, and a third, the Mexican grizzly, is now considered extinct as well.

Subspecies Range Extinction date Cause
U. a. crowtheri (Atlas bear) Morocco, Algeria, Tunisia, Libya c. 1870 Overhunting, firearms
U. a. californicus (California grizzly) California 1922 (last reported kill); last sighting 1924 Gold rush era bounty hunting
U. a. nelsoni (Mexican grizzly) Northern Mexico Last recorded sighting 1962 Hunting, ranching conflict

The Atlas bear is the only bear that was ever native to Africa in historical times. It had a brownish-black coat and reddish-orange underparts, and it died out shortly after modern firearms arrived, in the late 1800s. The last one recorded as killed by hunters was in the Tétouan mountains of northern Morocco in 1870, although that date is disputed.

The California grizzly appears on the California state flag and is still the official state animal of a place where it has been extinct for over a century. An estimated 10,000 once roamed the state, the last reported kill was in Tulare County in August 1922, with the last sighting in Sequoia National Park in 1924.


Polar Bears Are Brown Bears (Sort Of)

The strangest outcome of modern brown bear genetics is that the polar bear ( Ursus maritimus ) is, on mitochondrial DNA, nested inside the brown bear clade , not a sister species to all brown bears combined. Specifically, the brown bears of the ABC Islands of southeast Alaska carry polar bear mitochondrial DNA, presumably from polar bears left behind at the end of the Pleistocene, although their nuclear genomes are more than 90% brown bear.

What this means, taxonomically, is that Ursus arctos is a paraphyletic species, it does not contain all descendants of its common ancestor because polar bears have been split off as a separate species. Some genomicists have argued polar bears should be renamed Ursus arctos maritimus , i.e. a subspecies of the brown bear.

Most mammalogists have declined, partly because the two animals are so ecologically and morphologically different, and partly because confirmed wild hybrids ('pizzly' or 'grolar' bears) demonstrate ongoing gene flow without full species collapse. For a direct comparison, see the profile on the polar bear .


Subspecies Sizes Compared

A common question is how much size variation actually exists across living subspecies. The short answer is: an enormous amount. The article on how big brown bears are digs into the numbers population by population, but the summary looks like this.

Subspecies Male weight range Female weight range Notes
Kodiak (middendorffi) 270-635 kg 180-320 kg Largest living subspecies
Himalayan (isabellinus) 135 kg (Pakistan average) 70 kg (Pakistan average) High altitude
Gobi (gobiensis) 96-138 kg 51-78 kg Among the smallest brown bears

Coastal populations eating salmon consistently outweigh interior populations eating plants and ungulates, which is itself a strong argument that the old subspecies system is confounded with ecology. Whether a bear is big often depends on what is in the local river rather than what is in its genome. The feeding ecology is covered in depth in what do brown bears eat .


Conservation Status by Subspecies

The headline fact is that Ursus arctos as a species is listed as Least Concern by the IUCN. Estimates of the global population range from about 110,000 (IUCN, 2017) to 200,000. That headline hides a brutal patchwork underneath.

  • U. a. gobiensis (Gobi): Critically Endangered , ~31 individuals
  • U. a. isabellinus (Himalayan): Critically Endangered in parts of range
  • U. a. syriacus (Syrian): Endangered across most of range
  • Marsican or Apennine population (Italy, U. a. marsicanus to some authors): about 50 bears
  • Cantabrian population (Spain): Endangered , about 210 individuals (2013)
  • Pyrenean population (France/Spain): an estimated 20-25 animals in 2010, mostly descended from bears reintroduced from Slovenia
  • U. a. horribilis in contiguous US: Threatened under the ESA
  • U. a. crowtheri (Atlas): Extinct
  • U. a. californicus (California): Extinct
  • U. a. nelsoni (Mexican): Extinct

How the Names Will Keep Changing

Taxonomy is not fixed. Over the next decade, as whole-genome sequencing becomes cheap enough to run on hundreds of wild-caught samples, several of the currently-accepted subspecies will likely be merged or split again. The likely changes:

  • Kodiak and Alaska Peninsula bears may be merged into a single coastal clade, demoting middendorffi to a population rather than a subspecies.
  • ABC Islands bears may be formally split off as their own lineage, given their unusual polar-bear-adjacent ancestry.
  • The Gobi bear may be elevated to full species status by some authors, though this is contentious.
  • The Ussuri and Kamchatka subspecies may be merged or abandoned, depending on how nuclear DNA markers resolve.

What will not change is the underlying picture. There is one species, Ursus arctos , spread across the Holarctic in a handful of genetically distinct clades, with large populations in Russia and Alaska, threatened remnants in Europe and the Middle East, and a single, vanishingly rare desert population in Mongolia that would fit inside a single school gymnasium.

For readers who want to go deeper into the individual regional forms, the sibling articles on the Eurasian brown bear population in Europe , the grizzly as North American predator , and the Kodiak bear pick up from the subspecies framework laid out here. The species-level overview remains the main brown bear page, which ties together the physiology, hibernation, diet and reproduction shared by every form discussed above.


Frequently asked questions

References

  1. Lindqvist, C., Schuster, S. C., Sun, Y., et al. (2010). Complete mitochondrial genome of a Pleistocene jawbone unveils the origin of polar bear. Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences, 107(11), 5053-5057. View source
  2. Hailer, F., Kutschera, V. E., Hallström, B. M., et al. (2012). Nuclear genomic sequences reveal that polar bears are an old and distinct bear lineage. Science, 336(6079), 344-347. View source
  3. Miller, W., Schuster, S. C., Welch, A. J., et al. (2012). Polar and brown bear genomes reveal ancient admixture and demographic footprints of past climate change. PNAS, 109(36), E2382-E2390. View source
  4. Lan, T., Gill, S., Bellemain, E., Bischof, R., Nawaz, M. A., & Lindqvist, C. (2017). Evolutionary history of enigmatic bears in the Tibetan Plateau-Himalaya region and the identity of the yeti. Proceedings of the Royal Society B, 284(1868), 20171804. View source
  5. McLellan, B. N., Proctor, M. F., Huber, D., & Michel, S. (2017). Ursus arctos (amended version of 2017 assessment). The IUCN Red List of Threatened Species. View source
  6. Tumendemberel, O., Proctor, M., Reynolds, H., et al. (2015). Gobi bear abundance and inter-oases movements, Gobi Desert, Mongolia. Ursus, 26(2), 129-142. View source
  7. Calvignac, S., Hughes, S., & Hänni, C. (2009). Genetic diversity of endangered brown bear (Ursus arctos) populations at the crossroads of Europe, Asia and Africa. Diversity and Distributions, 15(5), 742-750. View source
  8. Davison, J., Ho, S. Y. W., Bray, S. C., et al. (2011). Late-Quaternary biogeographic scenarios for the brown bear (Ursus arctos), a wild mammal model species. Quaternary Science Reviews, 30(3-4), 418-430. View source

Tags