Do octopuses really have three hearts?

Yes, octopuses have three hearts. Two branchial hearts pump blood through the gills to oxygenate it, and one systemic heart pumps the oxygenated blood through the rest of the body. This arrangement is necessary because octopus blood carries oxygen inefficiently compared to vertebrate blood, they need extra pumping power to supply their highly active tissues.


The Most Alien Biology on Earth

If you wanted to design an alien, you could do worse than start with an octopus. Three hearts. Nine brains. Blue blood. Skin that sees color. Eight arms that think for themselves. A body with no bones that can squeeze through any hole bigger than its beak. An intelligence as sophisticated as a crow or a dog, evolved along a branch of the tree of life so different from our own that it is almost impossible to imagine what it is like to be one.

The octopus is the closest thing to an extraterrestrial intelligence we will ever find on this planet. Everything about it is strange, and almost all of it is true.

Three Hearts: The Oxygen Delivery Problem

Octopuses have three hearts.

Two of these, called branchial hearts , sit at the base of the gills. Their job is to pump blood through the gill tissue, where oxygen from seawater diffuses into the bloodstream.

The third, the systemic heart , is the central pump that pushes oxygenated blood from the gills out through the rest of the body. This is functionally equivalent to a vertebrate heart, but smaller and weaker.

Why three hearts instead of one?

Octopus blood is inefficient at carrying oxygen. The molecule they use, hemocyanin, binds less oxygen per volume than the hemoglobin found in vertebrates. To keep an active, fast-moving animal's tissues supplied, the octopus needs extra pumping capacity. Dedicating two small hearts to the gills accelerates oxygen uptake, and the systemic heart distributes the resulting high-oxygen blood.

There is a strange trade-off in this design. When an octopus swims by jetting water through its siphon, its systemic heart actually stops beating. Swimming is metabolically expensive for octopuses and hard on their circulatory system, which is why octopuses almost always prefer crawling over swimming when they can. A long swim exhausts them because the heart pauses during it.


Nine Brains: Distributed Intelligence

Octopuses have one central brain between the eyes, arranged around the esophagus in a donut shape. About one-third of the animal's neurons are in this central brain.

Each of the eight arms contains its own smaller brain, called a ganglion. Together, the arms hold about two-thirds of the animal's neurons, roughly twice as many as the central brain.

Total neuron count: over 500 million, around the same as a dog.

The octopus puts more neurons in its arms than in its head. This is not a design error, it is a different strategy for processing the world.


What Each Arm Can Do

Each octopus arm operates with significant autonomy. Experiments have shown that arms can:

  • Reach for objects independently when presented with food on the opposite side of a glass barrier. The arm finds its own path around the obstacle.
  • Continue reacting after severance . A severed octopus arm can still move and respond to stimuli.
  • Distinguish chemical information through receptors on the suckers. Each sucker has taste receptors that let the arm "taste" what it is touching without the central brain being involved.
  • Coordinate with neighboring arms without central brain input.

The central brain primarily issues general commands: "reach toward that object," "grip that food," "propel away from that threat." The arms handle the detailed motor control and sensory processing locally.

This distribution has a practical evolutionary reason. The octopus body is so flexible that tracking every joint position of every arm from a central brain would require enormous computing resources. Offloading motor control to the arms frees the central brain to focus on strategy, learning and decision-making.


Blue Blood: Copper Instead of Iron

Human blood is red because hemoglobin, the oxygen-transport molecule in our red blood cells, contains iron. Iron-oxygen complexes absorb blue and green light and reflect red, giving our blood its characteristic color.

Octopus blood is blue because it uses a different oxygen-transport molecule called hemocyanin , which contains copper instead of iron. Copper-oxygen complexes absorb red and yellow light and reflect blue.

Hemocyanin has several interesting properties:

  • It works better in cold water. Hemocyanin binds and releases oxygen efficiently at temperatures where hemoglobin becomes sluggish. Hemocyanin gives cephalopods an advantage in cold environments such as deep water and polar seas.

  • It works better in low-oxygen environments. The deep ocean often has low dissolved oxygen levels. Hemocyanin efficiently extracts oxygen at these concentrations.

  • It is much larger than hemoglobin. A hemocyanin molecule can bind up to 96 oxygen molecules, compared with four for hemoglobin. Hemocyanin floats freely in the blood plasma rather than being packaged inside red blood cells.

The larger molecule size is one reason octopus blood circulation requires three hearts. Pushing all those enormous molecules through narrow blood vessels takes more force than pushing smaller hemoglobin-filled blood cells.


Skin That Sees Color

Here is where octopus biology becomes almost unbelievable.

Octopuses are color-blind in their eyes. Their retinas contain only one type of photoreceptor, which means they cannot distinguish colors the way humans do.

Despite this, octopuses are the most color-accurate camouflage experts in the animal kingdom. They match their background color precisely, switching between patterns in fractions of a second. They blend with coral, sand, rock and even brightly colored tropical fish while remaining invisible.

How do they match colors they cannot see?

Research suggests octopus skin is photoreceptive. Their skin contains opsin proteins, the same light-sensitive proteins found in eyes, distributed throughout the body. These skin-based photoreceptors may allow octopuses to detect the color of their surroundings directly through their skin, bypassing their color-blind eyes entirely.


Shape-Shifting and Squeezing

Octopuses have no bones. The only rigid structure in the entire body is the beak, a parrot-like mouth piece made of chitin.

This bonelessness has consequences most vertebrates cannot imagine:

  • Octopuses can squeeze through any hole larger than their beak. Even large species can pass through a gap little more than 2.5 cm across.

  • Octopuses can change body shape radically. They can flatten themselves to slip under rocks, compress into narrow crevices, or expand to look larger.

  • Octopuses can mimic other animals. The mimic octopus (Thaumoctopus mimicus) of Indonesia can impersonate other animals, including lionfish and sea snakes. It changes shape, posture, skin texture, and color to match each mimicked species.

The cost of bonelessness is that octopuses cannot move quickly on land. They need buoyancy to support their body weight, so a stranded octopus quickly loses the ability to breathe or move effectively.


Problem-Solving and Tool Use

Octopuses are among the few invertebrates documented to use tools.

Coconut shell shelters. Veined octopuses ( Amphioctopus marginatus ) in Indonesia collect discarded coconut shells, stack them and carry them around the ocean floor. When threatened, the octopus climbs inside the stacked shells and closes them up. The octopus is not simply using a found object: it is collecting, transporting and assembling multiple objects for future defensive use. This is tool use by any reasonable definition.

Jar-opening. Octopuses in aquariums can unscrew jars with their suckers to retrieve food inside.

Escape artistry. Octopuses often break out of aquariums and sometimes into others in search of food. This is not instinctive behavior, it represents problem-solving in novel situations.

Recognizing individual humans. Octopuses can distinguish between individual people and treat them differently.


The Short Life

Despite all this complexity, octopuses live up to about four years and the life cycles of some species finish in less than half a year.

This shortness is a consequence of semelparity: reproducing once and dying. Female octopuses spawn thousands of eggs and then guard them for weeks or months without eating. They starve while fanning fresh water over the developing eggs. By the time the eggs hatch, the mother is dying. Males senesce after mating and die.

The evolutionary puzzle is profound. Intelligence normally evolves alongside long life, because complex cognition is an investment that pays off across many years of experience. An octopus has the intelligence of a dog or crow but lives as long as a mouse.

Theories for why include:

  • Octopus cognition is built for one lifetime of rapid learning rather than decades of accumulating wisdom.
  • The ancestor of modern octopuses was semelparous , and the body plan has not yet evolved away from it despite increased intelligence.
  • Short lifespans allow rapid generational evolution , which octopuses have exploited to diversify into hundreds of species occupying every marine niche.

No theory fully explains it. The question of why a mind this sophisticated evolved in a body that barely has time to use it remains one of the great unsolved puzzles of marine biology.


Independent Intelligence

Though octopuses and humans trace back to a common ancestor that lived around 600 million years ago, that ancestor was a simple flatworm-like creature possessing at most a nerve net and no brain. Both lineages have developed all their cognitive complexity entirely on their own since then.

This matters because it means octopus intelligence is a completely separate evolutionary experiment from vertebrate intelligence.

Studying octopuses tells us what intelligence fundamentally requires, if complex problem-solving can emerge from centralized and distributed nervous systems, from camera eyes and skin-embedded photoreceptors, from one brain or nine, then intelligence is not about any specific body plan. It is about what nervous systems can compute, regardless of shape.

The octopus is the closest thing to an alien mind we will ever encounter. It shares our planet, our oceans and in small ways our curiosity. But it thinks in ways we cannot easily imagine, through a body distributed across eight semi-autonomous arms, sensing the world through skin that may be able to see colors its eyes cannot.

When you look into an octopus's eye, you are looking at an intelligence that evolved along a completely separate path from your own. What it sees when it looks back is something we may never fully understand.


Neuron Counts and Comparative Intelligence

The octopus nervous system contains over 500 million neurons, with two-thirds of them distributed across the eight arms rather than in the central brain.

Octopus intelligence is particularly remarkable given that two-thirds of their neurons are distributed peripherally. A 2001 study by Sumbre and colleagues published in Science showed that octopus arm extension is controlled by a peripheral motor program in the arm itself [1].


Cephalopod Genomics and the Evolution of Intelligence

The 2015 sequencing of the Octopus bimaculoides (California two-spot octopus) genome by Caroline Albertin and colleagues at the University of Chicago revealed an extraordinary expansion of protocadherin genes, which regulate neuronal connection patterns. The octopus genome contains a large expansion of protocadherin genes [2].

The mRNA editing discovery is particularly remarkable. In most animals, genetic information flows faithfully from DNA to RNA to protein. In cephalopods, enzymes routinely rewrite adenosine bases in RNA messages to inosine, producing protein variants not directly encoded in the DNA.


The Evolutionary Roots of Semelparity

Octopus semelparity, the "die after reproducing" life history, is controlled by the optic gland, which produces hormones that trigger programmed senescence following egg-laying in females and mating in males. Surgical removal of the optic gland extends female octopus lifespan and eliminates the self-starvation behavior of egg brooding.

A 2018 study by Wang and Ragsdale implicated multiple optic gland signaling pathways in octopus maternal behaviors and death [3].


Frequently asked questions

References

  1. Sumbre, G., Gutfreund, Y., Fiorito, G., Flash, T., & Hochner, B. (2001). Control of octopus arm extension by a peripheral motor program. Science, 293(5536), 1845-1848. View source
  2. Albertin, C. B., Simakov, O., Mitros, T., et al. (2015). The octopus genome and the evolution of cephalopod neural and morphological novelties. Nature, 524(7564), 220-224. View source
  3. Wang, Z. Y., & Ragsdale, C. W. (2018). Multiple optic gland signaling pathways implicated in octopus maternal behaviors and death. Journal of Experimental Biology, 221(19), jeb185751. View source
  4. Godfrey-Smith, P. (2016). Other Minds: The Octopus, The Sea, and the Deep Origins of Consciousness. Farrar, Straus and Giroux, New York. ISBN: 978-0374227760

Tags