Why were prehistoric insects so much larger than modern insects?

The leading explanation for the size of prehistoric insects is the oxygen-gigantism hypothesis. During the Carboniferous period (approximately 359 to 299 million years ago), atmospheric oxygen concentrations reached roughly 35%, compared to today's 21%. Insects breathe through a network of tubes called tracheae that deliver oxygen passively to tissues. Higher ambient oxygen allowed these tubes to supply adequate oxygen to larger bodies.


Long before dinosaurs dominated the landscape, and hundreds of millions of years before humans took their first steps, insects had already claimed the Earth. They were the first animals to fly, and during one extraordinary window of geological time, they grew to sizes that would dwarf anything with an exoskeleton alive today. A dragonfly with the wingspan of a hawk.

A millipede longer than a car. Cockroaches that would not fit in your hand. This is the story of when bugs ruled the world, and what their rise and fall tells us about life on our planet today.

The Dawn of Insects: Origins in the Devonian

Strudiella devonica , described in 2012, is among the oldest fossils interpreted as an insect, a small, wingless creature unearthed from Devonian-era sediments in Strud, Belgium. Dated to roughly 370 million years ago in the Late Devonian, this tiny fossil represents a landmark in evolutionary history, although its identification as an insect has been debated.

However, molecular clock studies published in Science (2014) by Misof et al. push the estimated origin of insects back even further, suggesting the lineage may have diverged from other arthropods as early as 479 million years ago during the Ordovician period. If these estimates are correct, insects spent well over 100 million years evolving with almost no fossil record.

The Devonian world these early insects inhabited was profoundly different from today. Vascular plants had only recently begun colonizing land, forming the first primitive forests. Amphibians were just beginning to haul themselves out of the water.

Decaying plant matter, fungal mats and lack of vertebrate competition opened up ecological opportunities for small wingless hexapods in this transitional period. An explosion of insect diversity was about to unfold, which would reshape terrestrial ecosystems permanently.

By the Late Devonian, springtails, silverfish-like creatures and other primitive hexapods had diversified across the emerging land habitats. But it was the next geological period that would transform insects from minor players into the undisputed rulers of the terrestrial world.

The Carboniferous: An Age of Giants

Roughly 359 to 299 million years ago, the Carboniferous period witnessed the zenith of insect gigantism. What made this era exceptional was its atmospheric conditions. Massive swamp forests composed of lycopsid trees, ferns and early conifers spread across the supercontinent Pangaea, producing oxygen via photosynthesis at an unprecedented rate.

Oxygen levels in the atmosphere reached about 35%, versus the 21% we breathe now. This single environmental change would have reshaped the physical limits that insect bodies could achieve.

The Carboniferous coal swamps were extraordinarily productive ecosystems. Dead plant material accumulated faster than it could decompose, eventually forming the massive coal deposits that gave the period its name and, hundreds of millions of years later, would fuel the Industrial Revolution. In life, these forests created a humid, warm, oxygen-rich paradise for arthropods.

A 2012 study by Matthew Clapham and Jered Karr examined the environmental controls on insect body size through the fossil record, with atmospheric oxygen among the factors considered.

It was in this oxygen-saturated world that the most spectacular insect giants evolved.

Meganeura: The Hawk-Sized Dragonfly

Among the most iconic prehistoric insects is Meganeura monyi , a giant dragonfly-like predator that patrolled the Carboniferous skies with a wingspan of approximately 70 centimeters (27.5 inches). First described from a fossil discovered in Commentry, France, Meganeura was the apex aerial predator of its time, ruling the skies long before pterosaurs evolved.

Meganeura did not occupy the true dragonfly classification. This giant belonged to the order Meganisoptera, also known as griffinflies, an extinct group branching from the same ancestral stock as modern dragonflies and damselflies yet representing a separate evolutionary line. Beyond size alone, meganisopterans lacked specific wing-venation features present in contemporary odonates and probably flew differently, although they were evidently formidable aerial predators.

Meganeura had compound eyes giving it excellent vision, powerful mandibles and spiny legs adapted for catching prey while in flight. It likely fed on other large insects and possibly small amphibians.

The closely related Meganeuropsis permiana , from the early Permian, was even larger, with wingspan estimates reaching 71 centimeters (28 inches), making it the largest flying insect known to science.

Prehistoric Insect Size Modern Equivalent Modern Size
Meganeuropsis permiana (griffinfly) 71 cm wingspan Common green darner dragonfly 8 cm wingspan
Meganeura monyi (griffinfly) 70 cm wingspan Emperor dragonfly 10.5 cm wingspan
Arthropleura (giant millipede) 2.6 m length Giant African millipede 33 cm length
Pulmonoscorpius (giant scorpion) 70 cm length Emperor scorpion 20 cm length
Megarachne (eurypterid) 54 cm body length Goliath birdeater spider 12 cm body length

Arthropleura: The Monster Millipede

If Meganeura ruled the Carboniferous skies, Arthropleura was the undisputed giant of the forest floor. This enormous millipede-like arthropod reached lengths of 2.6 meters (8.5 feet), making it the largest land-dwelling invertebrate in the entire history of life on Earth.

Arthropleura occupied the Arthropleuridea, an extinct myriapod lineage that thrived during the Carboniferous period. Fossilized gut contents and trackways indicate Arthropleura was probably herbivorous or detritivorous, consuming the abundant nutrient-rich plant material found in swamp forests. Its colossal size would have rendered it essentially impervious to predation, no terrestrial vertebrate from that era was large enough to endanger an adult Arthropleura.

The Northumberland Discovery

January 2022 brought major news from University of Cambridge researchers about Arthropleura findings. A fossilized exoskeleton segment came to light in a sandstone block that had fallen from a cliff at Howick Bay, Northumberland, England. Chance discovery of the fossil in 2018 revealed it dated to roughly 326 million years ago.

While the size alone - the segment suggested the full animal was roughly 2.63 meters long - was striking, what made this specimen scientifically significant was its geological setting. The Northumberland Arthropleura was discovered in deltaic river sediments, not the dense coal swamp forests where such creatures had traditionally been assumed to thrive. Paleontologists were forced to reevaluate their understanding of where Arthropleura preferred to live.

Dr. Neil Davies of Cambridge's Department of Earth Sciences, lead author of the study published in the Journal of the Geological Society , described the find as a discovery made by chance.

The Northumberland fossil showed that giant arthropods attaining their largest sizes occurred during the early Carboniferous, prior to oxygen levels peaking. This finding suggests factors other than oxygen alone, including food availability and low predation pressure, worked together to enable their exceptional growth.

Giant Cockroaches and Ancestral Forms

Modern cockroaches inspire disproportionate dread for creatures that typically measure a few centimeters. Their Carboniferous ancestors, while not matching the scale of Meganeura or Arthropleura, were nonetheless considerably larger and more diverse than today's species.

Fossils from genera such as Archimylacris and Syscioblatta reveal cockroach-like insects (technically blattopterans, ancestral to both modern cockroaches and mantises). These were among the most abundant insects of the Carboniferous. Their flat, oval body plan, remarkably similar to modern roaches, was clearly an evolutionary winner from the start.

Unlike today's scavenging generalists, Carboniferous blattopterans occupied a wider range of ecological niches. Some appear to have been active forest-floor detritivores, others likely burrowed in decomposing logs, and some may have been semi-aquatic. Their success in the Carboniferous established a body plan and survival strategy so effective that cockroaches have persisted through every subsequent mass extinction, earning their reputation as nature's ultimate survivors.

Meganisoptera: The Griffinflies

The order Meganisoptera deserves attention beyond the famous Meganeura, as the group as a whole represents one of the most successful predatory insect lineages of the Paleozoic. Griffinflies ranged from moderately large to the record-breaking Meganeuropsis, and they persisted from the Late Carboniferous through the Permian.

Griffinflies differed from modern dragonflies (order Odonata) in several important ways. Their wing venation patterns were simpler, they lacked the specialized pterostigma (a thickened cell near the wingtip) seen in modern dragonflies, and their larval ecology remains largely unknown due to the rarity of immature-stage fossils. Whether griffinfly larvae were aquatic like modern dragonfly nymphs or terrestrial remains an open and debated question among paleoentomologists.

The dominance of griffinflies as aerial predators ended gradually through the Permian period as oxygen levels declined and new competitors emerged. Their extinction at the end of the Permian cleared the way for the radiation of true dragonflies and eventually the aerial supremacy of pterosaurs.

Giant Scorpions: Pulmonoscorpius and Terrestrial Terrors

While technically arachnids rather than insects, the giant scorpions of the Carboniferous shared the same oxygen-rich environment and grew to equally startling sizes. Pulmonoscorpius kirktonensis , described from fossils found in East Kirkton, Scotland, measured approximately 70 centimeters (28 inches) in length, more than three times the size of the largest living scorpions.

Pulmonoscorpius was an active terrestrial predator. Its large pedipalps (pincers) and robust stinger suggest it hunted other arthropods and possibly small amphibians on the Carboniferous forest floor. The genus name, meaning "breathing scorpion," references its well-preserved book lungs, a respiratory system that, like insect tracheae, benefited enormously from elevated oxygen levels.

Other notable Carboniferous arachnids included giant spiders such as Megarachne servinei , originally described as a spider but later reclassified as a eurypterid (sea scorpion). This taxonomic revision highlights the ongoing challenges of interpreting Paleozoic arthropod fossils, many of which are preserved as partial compressions in rock that can obscure critical anatomical details.

The Oxygen-Gigantism Hypothesis

One of the most elegant ideas in paleobiology links atmospheric oxygen directly to insect body size. Insects do not use lungs or hemoglobin for oxygen transport, instead they depend on a tracheal system that divides into a branching network of tubes opening at the body surface via tiny spiracle pores. Oxygen moves passively through these tubes to supply internal tissues with the needed gas.

While efficient at small scales, this diffusion-based system limits insects as their body size grows. The current atmospheric oxygen level at 21% constrains the maximum feasible size for tracheal-breathing insects because oxygen diffusion through the tubes becomes insufficient before metabolic concentrations drop too low. Experiments by Kaiser et al.

(2007) at Argonne National Laboratory used synchrotron X-ray imaging to demonstrate that tracheal tubes in modern beetles scale disproportionately with body size, larger beetles devote a progressively greater fraction of their body volume to respiratory infrastructure, which may limit maximum body size.

At 35% atmospheric oxygen, that diffusion limit shifts dramatically. Oxygen can penetrate deeper into larger tracheal systems, allowing insects to grow substantially bigger while still meeting their metabolic demands.

However, oxygen was likely not the only factor. The Northumberland Arthropleura finding and other research suggest that ecological conditions, abundant food, few large vertebrate predators and favorable climates, also played significant roles. The decline of insect gigantism correlates not only with falling oxygen levels in the Permian but also with the rise of early reptiles and amphibians large enough to prey on giant arthropods.

The Permian Extinction: End of the Giants

The Permian-Triassic extinction event, approximately 252 million years ago, was the most devastating mass extinction in Earth's history, wiping out an estimated 96% of marine species and 70% of terrestrial vertebrate species. For giant insects, the end came even earlier. Atmospheric oxygen had been declining through the Permian from its Carboniferous peak, and by the time the great extinction struck, most of the giant insect lineages were already gone or greatly diminished.

The Meganisoptera vanished entirely. Arthropleura had already gone extinct by the early Permian. Giant cockroach forms diminished in size. The Permian-Triassic event itself, driven by massive volcanic eruptions in the Siberian Traps, further crashed oxygen levels and created conditions hostile to any remaining large arthropods.

What emerged from the ashes of the Permian was a world fundamentally different for insects. Body sizes were smaller, but diversity would eventually explode in ways the Carboniferous never saw. The Mesozoic and Cenozoic would bring a different kind of insect dominance, one based on numbers, adaptability and co-evolution with the botanical revolution to come.

Insects and Flowering Plants: The Cretaceous Explosion

The most transformative event in insect evolutionary history was arguably not the Carboniferous oxygen spike but the rise of flowering plants (angiosperms) during the Cretaceous period, roughly 130 to 66 million years ago. This co-evolutionary relationship between insects and flowers reshaped both groups and produced the staggering diversity of insect life we see today.

Before angiosperms, insect pollination was limited and generalized. Beetles, flies and primitive wasps visited gymnosperms (conifers and cycads) for pollen and spores, but the relationship was loose and inefficient. The evolution of flowers, with their nectar rewards, vivid colors and targeted morphologies, created an entirely new ecological dimension.

Bees evolved from predatory wasp ancestors specifically in response to flowering plant proliferation. Butterflies and moths diversified explosively. Specialized flies, beetles and even some ants became dedicated pollinators. The result was a feedback loop: more diverse flowers selected for more specialized pollinators, which in turn drove further floral diversification.

Today, approximately 87.5% of flowering plant species depend on animal pollination, with insects handling the vast majority of that work.

The Cretaceous also saw the rise of social insects. Termites, ants and early social bees and wasps appeared during this period, their complex colonial structures representing some of the most sophisticated behaviors in the invertebrate world. A termite nest from the Cretaceous functions on principles remarkably similar to those of modern colonies, evidence that social organization was an early and stable evolutionary innovation.

Frozen in Time: Amber Preservation

No discussion of prehistoric insects is complete without amber, fossilized tree resin that has preserved insects in extraordinary three-dimensional detail for hundreds of millions of years. While compression fossils in rock provide outlines and general morphology, amber captures insects as if frozen mid-step, preserving fine hairs, wing venation, compound eye facets and even parasites attached to host bodies.

The oldest known insect preserved in amber dates to approximately 230 million years ago, from the Triassic Carnian stage. Found in the Dolomite Alps of northeastern Italy, these tiny inclusions in ancient conifer resin include mites and midges, providing a window into Triassic arthropod communities that rock fossils alone could never offer.

The most famous amber deposits for insect preservation include Baltic amber (approximately 44 million years old, containing an extraordinary diversity of Eocene insects), Dominican amber (15 to 20 million years old), and Burmese amber (approximately 99 million years old, yielding spectacular Cretaceous finds including feathered dinosaur tails and early bees).

Behavioral patterns invisible in the fossil record have emerged through amber inclusions. Worldwide amber deposits have yielded specimens showing ants carrying prey, wasps laying eggs inside hosts, mating pairs frozen mid-copulation and insects trapped alongside pollen they were collecting. Every amber piece captures ecological moments as time capsules, preserving behavior in addition to anatomy with striking detail.

The Modern Insect Decline: Echoes of Prehistoric Crashes

Today, global insect populations face what some researchers have termed an "insect apocalypse", though the scope and severity of the decline remain subjects of active scientific debate. A 2017 study from the Krefeld Entomological Society in Germany reported a 75% decline in flying insect biomass over 27 years in protected nature reserves. Subsequent studies have shown varying rates of decline across different regions and taxa, but the overall trajectory is concerning.

The parallels to prehistoric insect crashes are instructive, if imperfect. The Permian extinction was driven by volcanic-induced atmospheric changes, ocean acidification and habitat destruction on a planetary scale. Today's insect decline is driven by habitat loss, pesticide use, climate change, light pollution and invasive species, different mechanisms, but with similarly systemic effects on insect populations and the ecosystems that depend on them.

Insects currently comprise more than half of all known animal species, with total species counts estimated between 5.5 and 10 million. They pollinate crops worth hundreds of billions of dollars annually worldwide. They form the base of countless food webs. The loss of insect biomass cascades upward through ecosystems, affecting birds, bats, amphibians, freshwater fish and ultimately the agricultural systems that feed humanity.

The fossil record shows clearly that insects are resilient across geological time, they have survived every mass extinction event since they first appeared. But the record also shows that recovery from major population crashes takes millions of years. The Carboniferous giants never returned after conditions changed.

The question facing modern conservation is whether today's insect diversity, shaped by hundreds of millions of years of evolution, can withstand the pressures of the Anthropocene, or whether we are witnessing the opening chapter of a sixth great insect decline.

Are Prehistoric Animals Still Alive?

Some ancient insect lineages are: cockroaches, silverfish, mayflies and dragonflies all trace back to the Carboniferous period over 300 million years ago, though none approach the gigantic sizes of their ancestors. Modern dragonflies reach only 10-12 cm wingspans, compared to Meganeura monyi 's 70 cm and Meganeuropsis permiana 's 71 cm.

The Carboniferous giants required atmospheric oxygen at roughly 35 percent (versus today's 21 percent) to support their tracheal breathing systems. Horseshoe crabs, coelacanths and the tuatara survive from even older evolutionary branches, but the true Carboniferous giants, Arthropleura at 2.6 meters, Pulmonoscorpius at 70 cm, went extinct when atmospheric oxygen collapsed. Their modern relatives are a fraction of their former size.

Are There Prehistoric Animals Still Alive?

Yes, in the sense that many insect lineages have persisted for hundreds of millions of years. Cockroach ancestors such as Archimylacris lived in the Carboniferous, and modern cockroaches still carry that lineage. Dragonflies (Odonata) trace back over 300 million years, though they descend from sister groups of the extinct griffinflies (Meganisoptera).

Springtails and silverfish-like creatures from the Late Devonian still have living relatives today. However, no prehistoric animal from before the Permian extinction survives in anything close to its original form, Arthropleura , the giant millipede-like arthropod, has no modern counterpart.

Strudiella devonica , a Late Devonian fossil from roughly 370 million years ago, is one of the oldest fossils interpreted as an insect.

How Many Prehistoric Animals Are Still Alive?

Tens of thousands of species trace their lineages to prehistoric times, but none retains the scale of Carboniferous or Permian giants. Insects currently comprise more than half of all known animal species, with total counts estimated at 5.5 to 10 million, and many belong to orders established before the dinosaurs, cockroaches, dragonflies, mayflies, silverfish.

Modern giant African millipedes reach 33 cm, compared with Arthropleura's 2.6-meter length. Emperor scorpions reach 20 cm, versus Pulmonoscorpius at 70 cm. Goliath birdeater spiders span 12 cm body length, compared with the eurypterid Megarachne at 54 cm. The fossil record shows insects survived every mass extinction over hundreds of millions of years, but the giants did not return.

Illustration.


Frequently asked questions

References

  1. Misof, B., et al. (2014). "Phylogenomics resolves the timing and pattern of insect evolution." Science, 346(6210), 763-767.
  2. Clapham, M.E., & Karr, J.A. (2012). "Environmental and biotic controls on the evolutionary history of insect body size." Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences, 109(27), 10927-10930.
  3. Davies, N.S., et al. (2022). "The largest arthropod in Earth history: insights from newly discovered Arthropleura remains (Serpukhovian, Northumberland, England)." Journal of the Geological Society, 179(3).
  4. Kaiser, A., et al. (2007). "Increase in tracheal investment with beetle size supports hypothesis of oxygen limitation on insect gigantism." Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences, 104(32), 13198-13203.
  5. Hallmann, C.A., et al. (2017). "More than 75 percent decline over 27 years in total flying insect biomass in protected areas." PLoS ONE, 12(10), e0185809.
  6. Garrouste, R., et al. (2012). "A complete insect from the Late Devonian period." Nature, 488(7409), 82-85.
  7. Nel, A., et al. (2013). "The earliest known holometabolous insects." Nature, 503(7475), 257-261.

Tags